Is It Better To Build A Second Story Or An Addition?

When considering expanding living space in a home, homeowners will probably consider the benefits and drawbacks of choosing between building a second-floor or a ground-floor addition. Both options present unique advantages and drawbacks, influencing factors such as budget, property size, and lifestyle needs.

MSC Enterprises, LLC are Monmouth and Ocean County, New Jersey’s trusted and premier luxury custom home builders since 1999.

second-floor or a ground-floor addition new jersey

Our experience in building new homes as well as handling all types of remodeling projects and home renovations make us uniquely qualified to address this issue. In this discussion, we aim to examine the pros and cons of each choice, assisting homeowners in making a decision that best suits their specific circumstances.

Pros/Cons Of A Second Story


If you are looking to expand your living space without sacrificing your valuable outdoor space, adding a second story to your house can be the perfect solution for you! With a second story, there will be a valuable increase in your home’s square footage that can be used for extra bedrooms, bathrooms, or even a home office. Not only will this addition provide you with more living space, but a two-story can be worth more, a majority of the time, than a one-story house.

new jersey home renovation

A second story addition can be a savior for growing families who are constantly struggling for space. Having an increased amount of additional living space may just be the key to keeping your home organized, clutter-free, and peaceful. With an upper story gives you the opportunity to redesign your home, and change the external appearance of your house, leaving a lasting impression on visitors.


While adding a second story to your house might seem like a great way to increase space without sacrificing yard space, there are a number of cons to consider before making the leap. The most obvious issue is the increased cost – story additions typically cost more than simply renovating or adding onto your existing home’s ground floor footprint.

Make sure to keep in mind that second stories often require extensive structural changes to your home, which can be both time consuming and disruptive to your daily life. This could even mean dismantling parts of your existing roof.

It’s also important to consider the impact that adding a second story might have on your neighborhood. If your house suddenly towers over the rest of the homes on your street, it could significantly impact the value of your property and create tension with neighbors.

Pros/Cons Of Building Out Instead Of Up


Building out instead of up comes with a lot of benefits that are hard to ignore. For starters, expanding a property horizontally gives you more space to stretch out and customize with living room and garage additions according to your needs. Additionally, you don’t have to worry about the hassle of elevators, stairs, or the construction of extreme load bearing supporting walls since single-story buildings are generally easier to construct and maintain. With a low-rise structure, you can take advantage of natural light and scenery, creating a bright and inviting atmosphere.

Furthermore, expanding out allows for the integration of outdoor spaces such as patios, decks, and gardens, which provide a relaxing environment to unwind in. There are undoubtedly plenty of advantages to building out, and each one will contribute to a comfortable, spacious, and harmonious living or working environment.


As cities and populations grow, the demand for more living spaces also rises. However, building out instead of up has its cons. One of the main drawbacks is the loss of green space. Large neighborhoods with sprawling lawns and open spaces evaporate into an abundance of concrete as developers construct more and more homes and strip malls. Every square foot of green land is very valuable.

Expanding Living Space: Choosing Between a Second-Floor or Ground-Floor Addition in New Jersey

When homeowners contemplate expanding their living space, the choice between a second-floor addition or a ground-floor expansion often takes center stage. This decision hinges on various factors such as budget, property size, lifestyle requirements, zoning regulations, and future plans.

At MSC Enterprises, LLC, the premier luxury custom home builders in Monmouth and Ocean County, we understand the complexities of this decision.

Considering Zoning and Permits: Local zoning regulations and necessary permits play a pivotal role in any home expansion project. It’s essential to comprehend the rules governing each type of addition, as they can significantly impact the feasibility and timeline of your project. Our experienced team can guide homeowners and project managers through the regulatory landscape, ensuring a seamless and compliant expansion.

Architectural Design and Aesthetics: The architectural design not only determines the functional layout of your expanded space but also affects the overall aesthetics of your property. Building a second story might change the external appearance of your house and its compatibility with the neighborhood. In contrast, a ground-floor addition might blend more naturally with the existing structure. Our design expertise ensures that the chosen option aligns with your vision and enhances your home’s charm.

Impact on Property Value: Any expansion project should be viewed as an investment in your property’s value. Trends in the real estate market, buyer preferences, and the potential return on investment must be taken into account. Our team can provide data-driven insights into how each type of addition could influence the resale value of your home in the New Jersey market.

second floor addition in new jersey

Energy Efficiency and Sustainability: A pivotal consideration in today’s environmentally conscious landscape is the energy efficiency and sustainability of your home. Both second-story and ground-floor expansions have implications for heating, cooling, lighting costs, and overall energy consumption. Our expertise in sustainable design ensures that your chosen expansion aligns with your eco-friendly aspirations.

Future Flexibility and Resale: While planning for your current needs is essential, considering future scenarios is equally crucial. Whether it’s accommodating a growing family or preparing for a potential resale, the chosen expansion should offer flexibility. Factors such as the potential for further additions, alterations, or converting spaces should be taken into account. Our team can help you weigh these considerations against your long-term goals.

How To Choose Between Building Out Or Up

When it comes to expanding your living space, there are two main options: building out or building up. Building out means expanding the footprint of your home by extending into the yard, while building up involves adding another story onto your existing home.

There are several factors to consider when making this decision, such as your budget, lifestyle needs, and zoning regulations in your area. Building out may be a better option if you have ample yard space and want to have a larger single-level living area. However, if you have limited yard space, building up may be a better option to maximize your living space. Ultimately, the decision will depend on your personal preferences and needs.

Final Thoughts About Building Out Vs. Up

Deciding to expand your home vertically or horizontally is a decision influenced by a myriad of factors. Each choice has its unique benefits and potential challenges, and the optimal decision hinges on your specific situation and inclinations. Critical considerations should include budget constraints, available space, lifestyle requirements, and harmonizing with the neighborhood’s aesthetics.

The ultimate objective is to forge a living space that not only fulfills your functional needs, such as adding a family room or extending an exterior wall, but also augments the overall comfort, allure, and worth of your home. Regardless of the path you embark on, meticulous planning and insightful design are key to ensuring your home expansion project not only enhances your living experience but also escalates the value of your property.

Call 732-905-0005 or Contact Us to discuss plans for your New Jersey home renovation or addition today


  • Michelle Garofalo

    Michelle Garofalo is the guiding force behind MSC Enterprises, LLC, a prominent custom home builder and real estate developer in Monmouth County and Ocean County, New Jersey. With over 25 years in real estate development, her expertise extends from a successful career in the solar industry, where she managed over 75MW of projects. Co-founding Infiniti Energy, Michelle now oversees day-to-day operations and leads business development, ensuring a seamless journey for clients. Her meticulous approach and commitment to excellence are reflected in MSC's residential and commercial properties, known for their quality, durability, and energy efficiency.

    View all posts